Uncle Rhabdo Wants You
Portland’s CrossFit acolytes feel the burn.
Table of Contents: | Sidebar | Crossfit Lite: Photos From Recreate Fitness Workout
July 16th, 2008
Queer Window • My Big Fat Gay Wallet | When a billfold becomes a way of life.6 comments
July 16th, 2008
Hot Seat • LaJean Lawson | She follows the bouncing breast.2 comments
July 16th, 2008
SCOOP • Gossip should have no friends0 comments
July 9th, 2008
Berry Good | The time’s ripe for DIY pickers. 2 comments
July 9th, 2008
Hot Seat • Darrel Lee | Portland pastor builds near-term empire, fears long-term locusts.2 comments
July 9th, 2008
Wash, Rinse, Compete | Portland stylists head to Las Vegas for the ultimate hair showdown. 1 comment
July 9th, 2008
SCOOP • Gossip should have no friends0 comments
July 2nd, 2008
SCOOP • Gossip should have no friends0 comments
July 2nd, 2008
Queer Window • The Memorial Service | Burying a loved one digs up old feelings.6 comments
July 2nd, 2008
Face To Spinnaface | Who is Portland’s King of the Chrome? 7 comments
![]() IMAGE: Dennis Culver |
[May 14th, 2008]
In a garage-sized gym on Northwest Overton Street, I’m reliving my sixth-grade gym class.
The workout group at Recreate Fitness has just warmed up by skipping hopscotch, doing pull-ups on gymnastic rings and passing a ball back and forth as we ran around the block. Now, under the watchful eye of gym co-owner Tina Jeffers, I’m hoisting a sand-filled, 16-pound medicine ball over my sweaty head, slamming it to the floor and squatting to pick it up again. Next to me, a young blond woman heaves another medicine ball up at a big black X on the wall, while a well-muscled guy swings a kettlebell—a sort of cannonball with a handle, long used in Russian bodybuilding—between his legs. Part of me loved the aggression release, but part of me was thinking: This is the hot new workout routine everybody’s talking about?
The workout at Recreate Fitness was a softcore version of a punishing regimen known as CrossFit, which uses short, intense workouts with simple equipment—or no equipment—to pound out superfit athletes who are, in CrossFit creator Greg Glassman’s words, “equal parts gymnast, Olympic weightlifter and sprinter.”
Glassman, a personal trainer and former gymnast based in Santa Cruz, Calif., began developing the CrossFit program three decades ago, but it was the launch of Crossfit.com in 2001 that started pumping it up to a fitness phenomenon with more than 450 gyms around the country (and a few abroad) certified for training, three of them in Portland. Packed with video, message boards and links to affiliate gyms (along with the occasional right-wingnut link from Glassman), the site is a celebration of extending the limits of human capacity: As one T-shirt puts it, “Your Workout Is Our Warm-up.”
As The New York Times reported in 2005, however, other CrossFit T-shirts have illustrated the danger in ignoring human limits. “Pukey the Clown” shows some participants’ bomb-it-‘til-you-vomit workout approach. Pukey is downright cute compared with “Uncle Rhabdo,” a cartoon clown with his guts hanging out—a reference to the handful of people who have worked out so hard in CrossFit that they suffered rhabdomyolysis, a life-threatening condition in which the byproducts of muscle breakdown poison the kidneys.
Still, every day thousands of Spartans across the country check the homepage for the workout of the day, completing it as quickly as possible and often posting their times. A recent WOD (as the CrossFitters call it) was 21 deadlifts of a 225-pound barbell, followed by 21 handstand push-ups, followed by 15 of each, followed by nine of each; the fastest time posted was 3 minutes 37 seconds.
If that sounds like a workout conceived by a sadistic drill sergeant, there’s a reason. A big factor in CrossFit’s growth is its popularity with members of the military, police officers and firefighters, who say the workouts give them the extra speed, strength and agility they need for their dangerous jobs.
Janet Woodside, the Portland Fire Bureau’s wellness coordinator, says there’s strong interest in CrossFit training among Portland’s firefighters. “They keep asking me for kettlebells,” she says. While city rules prevent the bureau from associating with any particular CrossFit gym—“we’d have to let in every club in the city”—Woodside says the bureau is rustling up the $1,000 fee to get CrossFit certification for a firefighter who could then conduct trainings for the fire stations.
The chosen trainer is Kris Rotan, a firefighter and ultramarathoner who has been a CrossFit enthusiast for eight months. Rotan sees a direct relationship between CrossFit’s broad “functional training” and the duties of a firefighter. “The full body core workout is exactly what we’re doing when we’re on a roof swinging an ax, or when we’re dragging the hose through a building,” she says.
Along with about a dozen other firefighters, Rotan trains at a 5,000-square-foot cavern on Northeast Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard called CrossFit Human Evolution Labs, which unapologetically embodies the macho-mystical philosophy that drives athletes to push themselves beyond their limits. Above CrossFit HEL’s doorway is a Dante-esque warning, from the French poet Alfred de Musset: “Man is the student, pain is the teacher.”
The gym’s owner and head coach, Kevin Aillaud, is a former Navy midshipman and water-polo player who began his personal training career helping his shipmates pass the fitness exam. Like CrossFit nationally, he began by targeting that clientele; he estimates that 20 to 30 of CrossFit HEL’s 65 members are in the military, police or firefighting field. In order to earn their camo tee reading “Recruit”—the first level of achievement, in a progression that proceeds from “Basic” up to “Mutant”—athletes have to first go through a monthlong “boot camp” to learn the techniques and ready the body (the meal plan based on the Zone diet, for instance, nixes alcohol and caffeine).
advertisement
On the night I visited the gym, Aillaud swapped in a particularly challenging workout (see sidebar and video at wweek.com). Three men and two women, who looked like they had about a pound of fat to share among them, tore through the tasks, from “burpees” (a combination push-up and squat-thrust) to sprints to barbell lunges, box jumps and pull-ups, along with the now-familiar kettlebell swings, “wall ball” and “slam ball.” They were obviously pushing themselves hard, but no one appeared to sacrifice safe technique for the sake of time; if they faltered, they took a moment, adjusted and tried it again.
Of course, a certain amount of instructive pain is a given. “You don’t want to shake anyone’s hand around here, because we’re always bleeding,” said snowboarder and dental hygienist Sally Altree, displaying callused hands ravaged by the lifting and pull-ups.
Mike Mangan, a 31-year-old snowboarder and law student who has been doing CrossFit for a year, says it isn’t for everyone. “If you don’t understand your body enough to compete within your own limits,” he says, “there’s a danger you’re going to hurt yourself.”
Dr. Kerry Kuehl, an associate professor of medicine and co-director of the Human Performance Laboratory at Oregon Health & Science University, agrees.
“High-intensity athletes use CrossFit training, and that’s good for them,” he says, “but for the general population, no, it’s not good. Only 20 percent of the population exercise enough to get cardiovascular benefit…and CrossFit training is not appropriate for a sedentary or low-fit individual.” Try a daily 20-minute walk instead, Kuehl suggests, emphasizing the importance of keeping your heart rate within a safe range, whatever your fitness level.
So is CrossFit out for everyone but the superhuman fit-freaks? Not necessarily. Our city has a way of putting its own stamp on national trends—even militaristic, overly gung-ho, vaguely cultish ones.
Scott Hagnas co-owns CrossFit Portland, the city’s first affiliate club, which caters to athletes from adventure sports such as climbers and kayakers. “We put a Portland spin on our CrossFit,” says Hagnas, who last year quit the post office after 19 years to coach full-time. “Not a lot of machismo around here. And Mr. Rhabdo stays outside.”
Xi Xia, another co-owner, chimes in: “This is open-source fitness. People can build on it and make it what they want.”
Like, say, skipping hopscotch and playing catch with a big medicine ball?
“We really want people for the long haul,” says Recreate Fitness’ Jeffers, who started the gym with her husband, Nathan, last November. “We’re not looking to burn people out right away.
“At the end of the day, it’s just a workout.”
^SIDEBAR
Ian Gillingham’s workout, May 8:
450m run
21, 15 and 9 reps each of a 10-lb. wall ball, 16-lb. ball slams, 25-lb kettlebell swings
450m run
Time: 12:48
Mike Mangan’s workout, May 8:
50 burpees
400m run
20 hang, squat, clean, lunge (x2) split jerk (95 lb.)
30 pull-ups
400m run
30 box jumps (24 in.)
30 wall ball shots (10% body weight)
400m run
20 hang, squat, snatch, overhead lunge (x2) (45 lb.)
20 slam ball (20 lb.)
400m run
30 kettlebell swings (61.6 lb)
50 push-ups
400m run
50 burpees
Time: 34:49
^CrossFit Lite: Photos from Recreate Fitness workout
Ian--
I thought the story was terrific --- and unlike other media people, at least you went through the workout!
Still, perhaps you might have elaborated on more details about Crossfit. In what ways is it the "hot new workout"? Has participation increased, have more gyms opened, is there more media coverage?
Also, you neglected to address or define the theories behind Crossfit. How is it different from aerobics or weightlifting or gymnastics? For example, why do Crossfit workouts often pair complementary series of high-intensity interval training movements, sometimes using weights, under timed conditions?
You also do the system a bit of a disservice by neglecting to mention that Crossfit is entirely scalable, from amount of weights to specific exercises.
Crossfit is eminently scalable to all body types and all levels of fitness. The theories that underlie the system will work for anyone.
Here's hoping to see you at Crossfit Portland sometime --- as you've quoted Scott Hagnas, they've put a great Portland spin on it.
best,
jason S.
Characterizing Recreate Fitness as "lite" does it a disservice. We may not be throwing up in the bushes but I promise you it ain't a 20-minute stroll, either. As Jason says, it's entirely scalable - so this 44-year old can get as intense a workout as a 24-year old. And in a time when too few people are getting out and moving at all, I say, "Whatever works."
Great article Ian - thanks for coming out and spending the hour with us!
I have to agree with Matt Fullerton's comments. Like many MD's who have been educated in the old paradigm of fitness, i.e. a little cardio and a little weight training, usually separated, Dr. Kuehl's comments are based on lack of results based experimentation. Many 'sedentary and low-fit' individuals will begin a CrossFit training regimen and excel (due in part to the nature of the movements and in part to the belief the team has in the individual), while those who begin a conventional training program will not have the same rate of success. In fact, those who are considered 'sedentary', 'deconditioned', or 'low-fit' will find CrossFit to be safer than conventional methods of training because of the functional foundation that CrossFit offers. Combine this fact with the scalability that is necessary for beginners and there is simply no room for any other fitness program - CrossFit offers it all.
(Of course, there is a purpose in all things and for the sport specific bodybuilders out there - CrossFit isn't going to bulk you up. CrossFit only increases ability, not size.)








Great article, thanks for coming to HEL! Dr. Kuehl's impressions are very common among physicians with no practical experience inside a CrossFit facility.
I know a few grandmothers who would respectfully disagree- Google "think CrossFit is too hard?" for a great look at several CrossFitters who are proving him wrong.